Schedule Inspection
Use the calendar below to select a date & time convenient for you.
APPOINTMENT WINDOW: tech arrival time may vary by +/- 15 minutes (if your appointment is 9:00am, arrival window would be 8:45-9:15am)
Hailstorms in Tulsa can wreak havoc on flat roofs, often causing damage that’s hard to spot but costly to ignore. Here’s what you need to know:
- Flat roofs, common in commercial buildings, are prone to punctures, seam stress, and water pooling after hailstorms.
- Damage isn’t always visible. Issues like membrane bruising, flashing gaps, and clogged drains can lead to leaks months later.
- Act fast: Oklahoma insurers typically allow only 1 year to file a hail damage claim.
- Schedule a professional inspection within 30–60 days of a storm to catch hidden problems early.
Key signs to watch for:
- Punctures, cracks, or bruises in TPO, EPDM, or BUR membranes.
- Weak or damaged seams and flashing around HVAC units or parapet walls.
- Ponding water caused by clogged drains or low spots.
- Cracked skylights or damaged rooftop equipment.
Don’t wait for visible leaks. Addressing minor damage now can prevent costly repairs later. For free inspections in Tulsa and nearby areas, contact Arrowhead Roofing at (918) 743-9257.
What does hail damage look like on a flat roof? Membrane roofing like EPDM, TPO, PVC, and Mod Bit?
sbb-itb-a7e0f83
Signs of Hail Damage on Flat Roofs
After a hailstorm sweeps through Tulsa, Broken Arrow, Owasso, or nearby areas, flat roof damage may not be immediately obvious. The signs are often subtle, but in the face of Tulsa’s intense weather, even minor damage on flat roofs needs prompt attention.
Punctures, Blisters, and Exposed Membrane Fabric
The type of roofing material determines how damage appears. For example:
- TPO/PVC membranes: These can fracture under hail impact.
- EPDM roofs: These may crack, especially when the material softens.
- BUR systems: Hail can strip away the asphalt layer, exposing it to direct UV rays.
One less obvious issue is membrane bruising. These are slight depressions that feel soft to the touch, often signaling internal damage even when there’s no visible tear. While standard TPO membranes are designed to handle hailstones up to 1.75 inches in diameter, their durability decreases as they age and become more brittle.
“Hail damage ‘counts’ when it weakens waterproofing, not just when it looks dramatic.” – Ted Sellers, Owner, Sellers Roofing Company
Seam Stress and Flashing Damage
Hailstorms often target the most vulnerable parts of a flat roof: seams and flashings. For TPO membranes, heat-welded seams can weaken under impact without obvious tears. EPDM roofs face a similar issue, where seam tape or adhesive may lose its seal while the membrane itself appears intact.
In areas like Tulsa and Broken Arrow, hail can also damage sealant joints around curbs, parapet walls, and penetrations. These weakened points may not show leaks immediately, but water can seep through over time, leading to problems that surface months later.
“If you only check the obvious dents, you’ll miss the real risk – damaged seams and flashings that fail months later.” – Ted Sellers, Owner, Sellers Roofing Company
Beyond these direct impacts, hailstorms can also disrupt drainage systems.
Ponding Water and Clogged Drains
Hailstorms often leave behind debris that clogs drains, creating dangerous ponding water. This includes leaves, branches, and hail fragments that block scuppers and internal drainage systems. Ponding water – defined as water that remains stagnant for more than 48 hours after rainfall – puts extra weight on the roof structure and speeds up membrane wear. On a roof already weakened by hail, this additional stress can turn minor damage into significant leaks much faster.
Skylight and Rooftop Equipment Damage
Skylights, HVAC units, and vent caps are often the first to take a beating during a hailstorm. While a dented condenser fin might not seem like a big deal, the real concern lies in the curb flashings, pitch pans, and sealant joints around these units. For instance, a damaged HVAC curb corner can allow water to seep in and travel as far as 30 feet across the roof deck before it shows up as an interior stain.
Skylights, on the other hand, face a different risk. Large hailstones – about 2 inches in diameter, the size of a hen’s egg – can crack glazing or compromise the frame seal entirely.
Coating Erosion and Surface Wear
In the Tulsa area, many commercial flat roofs rely on reflective coatings, such as silicone or acrylic, to protect against UV rays and water. Hailstorms can wear down these coatings unevenly, leaving sections of the membrane exposed. Unlike punctures, this type of damage is often overlooked during routine inspections. Once the protective layer is compromised, the membrane deteriorates faster, becoming brittle and more vulnerable to future storms.
Flat Roof Components Most Affected by Hail
Hailstorms don’t affect every part of a flat roof equally. Some components are designed to handle impact better than others, while certain areas are more prone to damage. Identifying these vulnerable spots can make post-storm inspections more efficient, especially in areas like Tulsa, Jenks, or Sand Springs, where severe weather is common.
Membranes and Seams
Flat roof membranes take the brunt of hail impacts, with damage varying based on the material. For instance:
- TPO and PVC membranes often show semicircular “frown” cracks or fractures in the scrim, the internal reinforcement fabric.
- EPDM membranes, known for their flexibility, resist surface damage better. However, large hailstones can crush the rigid insulation board beneath, causing the membrane to detach from its base.
- Built-up roofing systems (BUR) lose their protective gravel layer, exposing the felt underneath to UV damage and water infiltration during the next storm.
Seams, however, are where hidden risks often lurk. Even if the membrane surface seems fine, repeated hail impacts can weaken the bonds at the seams. On TPO roofs, heat-welded seams may loosen, while adhesive-taped seams on EPDM roofs can fail. Once a seam opens, water has a direct path inside.
Flashings, Drains, and Skylights
Metal components like edge metal, coping caps, and counterflashing are highly susceptible to hail damage. Impacts can deform these parts, causing them to pull away from their sealing surfaces. These gaps, especially around roof edges and parapet walls, are common entry points for water after a storm.
Drains and scuppers face a different challenge. Hailstorms often push debris – gravel, insulation pieces, and leaves – into drainage systems. This debris clogs drains, leading to pooling water that seeps into any cracks or loosened seams created by the storm.
“A small puncture, displaced flashing, clogged drain, or compromised seal may not result in an active issue during the storm, but it may become a future water entry point during subsequent rain events.” – Jerry Griswell, Senior Project Manager, Intertek
Skylights are particularly vulnerable. Both the frame seals and the glazing can fail under hail impact. Once the seal breaks, water intrusion is almost inevitable.
Rooftop Equipment and Coatings
Hail can severely damage HVAC systems by bending the metal fins on condenser coils – a process often called “combing.” It can also compromise curb flashings, allowing water to spread across the roof deck before showing up as a ceiling stain inside the building.
Protective coatings on modified bitumen and BUR systems aren’t immune either. Hail can cause surface fractures and lead to granule loss, exposing the asphalt beneath. This exposure accelerates UV damage, weakening the membrane and leaving it more vulnerable to future storms.
Why Flat Roof Hail Damage Often Causes Slow Leaks
Flat roof hail damage can be deceptively hard to spot. After a storm in Tulsa or Broken Arrow, everything might look fine from ground level. But beneath the surface, hidden issues could already be forming, setting the stage for future leaks.
Micro-Damage to Membranes and Open Seams
Hail doesn’t need to punch visible holes in a roof to cause trouble. On TPO and PVC membranes, hail impacts can leave behind subtle spiderweb fractures or circular stress marks. These tiny cracks are easy to overlook during a quick inspection. At first, they don’t leak. But over time, daily temperature changes cause these micro-cracks to expand, eventually turning them into active leaks.
“Even the smallest micro-cracks will expand with daily thermal movement, eventually pulling apart and leading to active leaks that disrupt your interior workspace.” – All Seasons Roofing
EPDM membranes are more resistant to direct impact, but they’re not invincible. Large hailstones can crush the rigid insulation board beneath the surface, creating soft spots without visible damage. These areas lose their bond to the roof substrate, trapping moisture and weakening the roof’s ability to withstand wind uplift during the next storm.
In addition to micro-cracks, weakened flashings can quietly worsen the situation, laying the groundwork for leaks that grow over time.
Damaged Flashing and Insulation
Flashing is often one of the first casualties of hail damage, yet it’s frequently overlooked. When hail bends or loosens the metal around HVAC units, parapet walls, or roof edges, gaps form. These gaps allow water to seep in during the next rainstorm. Water can then travel laterally beneath the roof, causing interior damage far from the original entry point.
This type of delayed leak can lead to hidden problems inside, such as saturated insulation. Wet insulation loses its R-value, forcing HVAC systems to work harder and driving up energy bills – often before a single indoor drip is noticed. Tulsa’s intense summer heat and UV exposure only speed up this process, especially on older membranes that have already lost their flexibility.
Water Intrusion That Gets Worse With Each Storm
Once the initial damage is done, every subsequent storm makes things worse. Rain pushes more water through weakened seams and gaps in flashing. Hail indentations often create tiny low spots – micro-ponds – where water collects and puts constant pressure on already-compromised areas of the membrane.
“Treat ‘no leak today’ as a temporary snapshot, not a clean bill of health.” – Ted Sellers, Owner, Sellers Roofing Company
This compounding damage highlights the importance of acting quickly. A small flashing repair that costs a few hundred dollars today could snowball into a major repair involving the deck and interior if left unaddressed. For commercial property owners in areas like Owasso, Jenks, Bixby, and Sand Springs, where severe weather is a regular occurrence, the window between minor damage and a major problem can close faster than expected.
Post-Storm Inspection Checklist for Tulsa Property Owners
After a hailstorm hits areas like Tulsa, Broken Arrow, or Owasso, following a systematic roofing action plan is crucial. A quick glance at your roof might not reveal the full extent of the damage. Start at ground level and work your way up for a clearer understanding of the storm’s impact.
Ground-Level and Interior Warning Signs
Spend 15–20 minutes walking around the property. Look for dents on gutters, downspouts, and vent caps – these areas often show damage before the roof itself. Don’t forget to check AC condenser fins and rooftop unit screens for dings. If these parts are damaged, there’s a good chance the roof has been affected too.
Inside the building, inspect top-floor ceilings, walls near the roofline, storage spaces, and utility rooms. Watch for water stains, peeling paint, or musty odors, as these can indicate moisture entering through a damaged roof membrane – even if there’s no active leak. Take photos of any findings, including hail remnants, damaged gutters, and interior water stains. This documentation can be invaluable for insurance claims and helps establish a timeline for the damage. Catching these issues early can prevent the slow leaks we’ve discussed before.
Roof-Level Damage Indicators
If it’s safe to access the roof, inspect for punctures, tears, or areas that feel soft underfoot. On TPO and EPDM membranes, check for semicircular cracks or spongy spots, which may point to insulation damage underneath. Pay close attention to the seams – heat-welded seams on TPO roofs and taped seams on EPDM are common weak points after hailstorms, though the damage might not be immediately obvious.
Make sure to examine drains and scuppers for blockages. Ponding water that lingers for more than 48 hours after a storm could signal a clogged drain or even structural sagging, both of which can speed up membrane deterioration. Also, inspect termination bars, wall flashings, and areas around HVAC curbs or parapet walls. These spots are particularly vulnerable to hail impact and should be checked carefully. If you notice any of these issues, it’s time to call in a professional for a deeper assessment.
When to Call a Professional Roofing Contractor
Not all damage is visible to the untrained eye. Micro-fractures in the membrane, damage to insulation beneath the surface, and stressed seams often require specialized tools and expertise to detect.
“A roof can be watertight today and still be storm-damaged.” – Hail King Professionals
It’s a good idea to schedule a professional inspection within 30–60 days of a major storm. This ensures any damage is documented before the next weather event. A professional inspection not only identifies visible problems but also uncovers hidden issues that could lead to costly repairs if left unchecked. This is especially important for commercial properties like warehouses, retail centers, churches, schools, and multifamily buildings, where larger roofs have more potential failure points.
Before hiring a contractor, make sure they’re registered in Oklahoma by checking verifyroofing.cib.ok.gov. Be cautious of contractors who offer to “cover your deductible”, as that practice is illegal in Oklahoma.
Arrowhead Roofing provides free post-storm inspections for commercial property owners throughout Tulsa and nearby areas, including Broken Arrow, Jenks, Bixby, Sand Springs, and Owasso. To schedule an inspection, call (918) 743-9257 or visit their website at arrowheadroofing.com.
Repair or Replace: Judging the Extent of Hail Damage
Once you’ve thoroughly inspected your roof, the next step is deciding whether repairs will do the job or if a full replacement is necessary. This decision hinges on the extent of the damage, the roof’s age, and whether the insulation underneath remains intact. Here’s how to weigh your options.
Minor Surface Damage and Localized Repairs
If the damage is limited to specific areas – like a single puncture, a small seam split, or minor flashing problems – a targeted repair might be all you need. This is particularly true for roofs that still have a solid amount of service life remaining. For instance, if your roof is less than 10–12 years old and the insulation beneath is dry and structurally sound, a professional can often fix the issue without replacing the entire system.
Act quickly with these minor repairs to prevent water from infiltrating and causing bigger problems down the line.
Widespread Damage and Replacement Considerations
When the damage is more extensive, a full replacement may be the better route. Many insurance companies use a benchmark of eight or more impact marks within a 10-by-10-foot test square to justify replacing the roof instead of patching it. Beyond this threshold, consider the following factors:
| Factor | Repair | Replace |
|---|---|---|
| Roof age | Under 10–12 years old | 15–20+ years old |
| Insulation | Dry and intact | Saturated or compressed |
| Seam condition | Isolated issues only | Failing across multiple zones |
| Damage pattern | Scattered, limited area | Widespread bruising or compromise |
| Repair history | No major prior issues | Repeated leaks or existing defects |
Saturated insulation is a key warning sign. Once water seeps into the insulation, it can spread laterally beneath the surface, creating larger hidden problems. Tools like infrared thermography and core sampling are the most reliable ways to detect this kind of damage. After assessing the visible and underlying issues, consult a professional for a clearer understanding of whether repair or replacement is the best solution.
Professional Evaluations and Roof Maintenance Plans
A professional evaluation not only documents the current state of your roof but also sets a solid foundation for any future insurance claims. Keep in mind that insurance adjusters often use standardized templates that may not account for the specific type of roofing system on your property. Having an independent assessment beforehand strengthens your position.
It’s also essential to schedule regular maintenance checks after any storm. Small hail fractures can worsen over time due to temperature changes, eventually leading to leaks. A proactive maintenance plan, with inspections every six to twelve months, can catch these issues early – saving you from costly repairs or damage to your property.
For those in the Tulsa area, including Broken Arrow, Owasso, Jenks, Bixby, and Sand Springs, Arrowhead Roofing offers ongoing maintenance programs for commercial properties. You can contact them at (918) 743-9257 or visit arrowheadroofing.com for more information.
Conclusion: Take Action After a Tulsa Hailstorm
Severe weather in Tulsa can leave behind more than just visible damage to your flat roof. Subtle issues like membrane bruising, stressed seams, damaged flashings, or clogged drains can quickly escalate into costly leaks if left unchecked. These hidden problems allow water to seep in, saturate insulation, and cause significant damage over time.
Tulsa’s fluctuating temperatures only make things worse, especially for commercial buildings, warehouses, and multifamily properties in areas like Broken Arrow, Owasso, Jenks, Bixby, and Sand Springs. A small, unnoticed leak can harm inventory, disrupt tenants, or weaken structural components before anyone realizes there’s an issue.
Time is critical here. Most insurance claims must be filed within a year of the storm, so delaying repairs not only increases the risk of further damage but could also jeopardize your coverage.
Don’t wait until it’s too late. Protect your property by addressing potential risks now. Arrowhead Roofing, serving the Tulsa area since 1987, specializes in TPO, EPDM, and modified bitumen flat roof systems. They provide free professional inspections to uncover hidden damage like membrane bruising or seam stress. As Oklahoma’s oldest GAF Master Elite® contractor – a distinction held by less than 2% of roofing contractors nationwide – they also assist with insurance documentation and claims and help you navigate repair or replacement options.
Take the first step today. Call (918) 743-9257 or visit arrowheadroofing.com to schedule your free inspection.
FAQs
Can hail damage a flat roof even if there are no leaks yet?
Yes, hail can harm a flat roof even if leaks aren’t immediately visible. Hailstones can crack the membrane, damage the internal reinforcement fabric, or bruise the insulation beneath. These problems compromise the roof’s ability to keep water out, potentially leading to slow-developing leaks that might not show up for months – or even years. On top of that, flat roofs often allow water to travel far from the original impact site, making it even tougher to spot damage early on.
What hail size is enough to damage TPO, EPDM, or BUR flat roofs?
The size of hail that can damage flat roofs varies depending on the roofing material and its condition. TPO membranes are generally resistant to hail up to 1 3/4 inches in diameter. EPDM roofs, on the other hand, can endure hailstones as large as 2 1/2 inches. For BUR systems, while they are sturdy, hail measuring around 1 1/2 inches can cause issues by displacing the protective gravel layer. However, for all roofing systems, hail over 1 inch poses a greater risk, particularly if the roof is aged or already compromised.
What proof do I need for a hail insurance claim on a flat roof?
To file a hail insurance claim, you’ll need proof of functional damage from the storm, not just surface-level wear. Start by taking clear photos – both wide-angle shots and close-ups. Make sure to include the storm date and any local weather alerts as part of your documentation.
Insurers often request a professional inspection, which might involve tests like core sampling or moisture mapping. Be thorough by noting other signs of damage, such as dents in gutters or vents. To support your claim further, get a detailed report from a qualified roofer outlining the extent of the damage.