Schedule Inspection
Use the calendar below to select a date & time convenient for you.
APPOINTMENT WINDOW: tech arrival time may vary by +/- 15 minutes (if your appointment is 9:00am, arrival window would be 8:45-9:15am)
What Is Recoverable Depreciation on a Roof Claim?
Home » Roofing Guide » Insurance »
Recoverable depreciation is the part of a replacement cost settlement your carrier holds back until the work is actually finished, which is why a roof claim usually arrives as two checks rather than one. The first is the actual cash value, meaning the cost of the work minus depreciation for the age and condition of the old roof. The second releases the depreciation once the job is done and documented. Arrowhead Roofing has worked storm claims across Tulsa since 1987, and this is the single most common reason a homeowner thinks their claim came in short when it did not.
Note: this is a general explanation of how replacement cost settlements are structured. It is not a statement about any particular policy. Arrowhead Roofing is not a licensed public adjuster and we do not negotiate insurance claims. What your policy covers, and whether depreciation on it is recoverable, is determined by your policy and your carrier.
Three terms do all the work in this conversation, and they are worth separating before anything else.
| Term | What It Means | When You See It |
|---|---|---|
| Replacement cost value | What it costs to put the roof back today | The total figure on the estimate |
| Depreciation | A deduction for the age and condition of what was there | Subtracted on the first settlement |
| Actual cash value | Replacement cost minus depreciation | The first check |
| Recoverable depreciation | The held-back portion, released once work is complete | The second check |
| Non-recoverable depreciation | A portion that is not released at all | Stays with the policyholder |
The Short Answer
On a replacement cost policy the carrier does not hand over the full figure up front, and the reason is straightforward: they are paying to have the roof replaced, so the balance is tied to it actually being replaced.
The archive of this company’s own writing put it plainly decades ago, and it is still the clearest version: the depreciation holdback is standard on all claims. It is not a penalty and it is not a sign that anything is wrong with the claim.
What releases it is completion plus paperwork, filed inside whatever window the policy allows.
The Two Checks, in Order
Understanding the sequence removes most of the anxiety around it.
The first check is the actual cash value. It arrives after the claim is approved and it is smaller than the estimate, because depreciation has been subtracted. If your roof was fifteen years into a thirty year expectancy, a meaningful share of the value has been depreciated out.
The work happens. Nothing is released until it does.
The second check releases the recoverable depreciation. The final disbursement typically includes the held depreciation together with any additional adjustments the carrier authorised along the way.
There is a deadline, and it is the part people miss. A replacement cost policy generally requires the work to be completed and the billing submitted within a period set by the policy. Miss that window and the recoverable portion may not be recoverable any more. Your policy is where that period is written.
Recoverable and Non-Recoverable Are Not the Same Thing
Some depreciation comes back and some does not, and the difference is in the policy rather than in the roof.
On a replacement cost policy, depreciation is generally recoverable once the work is done. On an actual cash value settlement, or under a roof schedule that settles an older roof at actual cash value, some or all of the depreciation is non-recoverable, which means it stays with the policyholder along with the deductible.
Roof schedules based on age have become more common in Oklahoma than they were a few years ago. That is a real change and it is worth reading your declarations page for, ideally before a storm rather than after one.
Why Your Mortgage Company Is on the Check
Because they have a stake in the building, and this catches people out every time.
Where there is a mortgage, claim checks are typically made payable to the policyholder and the mortgage company together. That is standard and it is not a comment on you. What varies is what the lender does next, and every lender is different.
Some will endorse the check over to you against a copy of the contract. Others deposit it into an escrow account and disburse in stages as the work is completed, often with an inspection before the final release. Their policy will be in the lending documents you signed, and their loss draft department will tell you which one applies.
What Changes the Answer
Three things decide how much of the depreciation you actually see, and none of them is negotiable after the fact.
Whether the policy settles at replacement cost or actual cash value
The single biggest factor. A replacement cost policy holds depreciation back and releases it. An actual cash value policy does not hold it back, because it never included it.
How old the roof was
Depreciation is calculated against age and condition, so an older roof carries a larger holdback and a larger first gap. The total does not change; the shape of it does.
Whether the work gets completed and documented in time
The recoverable portion is recoverable because work was done. Completion, an invoice, and submission inside the policy’s window are what turn it from a number on a page into a payment.
What We Do, and What We Do Not Do
We provide the completion documentation a carrier asks for: the final invoice, the scope of work as performed, and photographs of the completed job. That is the paperwork that supports releasing a depreciation holdback.
Arrowhead Roofing is not a licensed public adjuster. We do not negotiate insurance claims. Questions about what your policy covers belong with your carrier or your agent, and after that with the Oklahoma Insurance Department’s consumer assistance line on 1-800-522-0071.
Related Questions
Is this the same as the estimate coming in low?
No, and they get confused constantly. A holdback is money deliberately withheld until completion; an estimate gap is a difference in scope or pricing. Why is the insurance estimate lower than the contractor’s estimate? covers the other one.
How is the roof’s age worked out for depreciation?
From the shingle, the paperwork, or the wear, and you can often do it yourself. How old is my roof, and can it still be repaired? covers the methods.
Does a new roof do anything for me at tax time?
Not as a deduction on your own home, but it changes your cost basis, and an insurance settlement affects how that works. Is a new roof tax deductible? covers all four situations.
Is overhead and profit held back the same way?
It is a separate line from depreciation and it is argued on entirely separate grounds. What are overhead and profit on an insurance claim? covers what is actually published about when it is owed, which is less than people think.
See Also
The two answers next to this one are why the first number comes in low, and how the claim gets documented in the first place.
Get the Completion Paperwork Right the First Time
We have worked storm claims in northeast Oklahoma since 1987, and a depreciation release stalls on paperwork far more often than on disagreement. Book a free roof inspection and we will document the job from the first photograph to the final invoice.