Schedule Inspection
Use the calendar below to select a date & time convenient for you.
APPOINTMENT WINDOW: tech arrival time may vary by +/- 15 minutes (if your appointment is 9:00am, arrival window would be 8:45-9:15am)
Why Do Insurance Companies Deny Roof Claims, and What Comes Next?
Home » Roofing Guide » Insurance »
The most common reason a roof claim is denied is wear and tear, meaning the carrier has concluded the roof is worn out rather than storm damaged. That is a technical conclusion, which means it can be answered with technical evidence rather than argument, and the strongest single piece of that evidence is colour: freshly exposed asphalt is black and weathers to chalky grey over months. Arrowhead Roofing has worked storm claims across Tulsa since 1987, and a denial is more often a documentation problem than a coverage problem.
Note: this is a general explanation of why roof claims get declined and how damage is documented. It is not a statement about any particular policy or claim. Arrowhead Roofing is not a licensed public adjuster and we do not negotiate insurance claims. What your policy covers is determined by your policy and your carrier.
Five grounds account for most declined roof claims, and they are not equally answerable.
| Reason Given | What It Means | What Addresses It |
|---|---|---|
| Wear and tear | The damage is age, not an event | Colour of exposed asphalt, fracture edges, a properly placed test square on each slope |
| Not enough damage | Below the carrier’s threshold for replacement | Squares run on every direction rather than one, plus soft metals and ridge caps |
| Cosmetic only | Marks that do not affect performance | Evidence of fractures in the mat rather than dents and granule scatter |
| Outside the policy period | The damage predates the coverage or the claim window | Dating evidence, and the storm record for the address |
| Excluded or scheduled | The policy itself limits or excludes it | Nothing on the roof. This one is in the policy, and it is a question for your carrier |
The Short Answer
There are two very different kinds of denial and it is worth knowing which one you have, because only one of them is about your roof.
Worth knowing before either: Oklahoma sets out what counts as an unfair claim settlement practice in statute, at 36 O.S. 1250.5, and the list includes failing to adopt reasonable standards for the prompt investigation of claims.
A factual denial says the damage is not there, is not enough, or is not from the event. That is a technical disagreement and technical evidence speaks to it.
A coverage denial says the policy does not cover this loss, or covers it on different terms. That has nothing to do with what is on the roof, and no amount of photography changes it. Your carrier or your agent is the only party who can explain it.
Most homeowners treat every denial as the second kind and give up. A good share of them are the first kind.
Wear and Tear, and Why It Is Answerable
This is the big one, and Andy Anderson at Arrowhead is blunt about how often it comes up: “Even if it’s hail damage, they say it’s wear and tear.”
Here is why that is answerable rather than final. Wear and tear is a claim about when something happened. Asphalt weathers by photo-oxidation in a direction anybody can observe: recently exposed asphalt is black, and asphalt exposed for several months oxidises into a chalky grey surface film. Fracture edges start sharp and round off over years.
So a slope of impacts with black exposed asphalt and sharp edges is describing a recent event, and that is checkable from a photograph by somebody who was never on the roof.
Two honest caveats. The colour test dates an exposure; it does not identify what caused it. And a Tulsa roof that has been through two dozen hail events in three years will show old and new together, so the question is whether there is a fresh population on top of the old one.
What Actually Happens Next
A denial is not necessarily the end of the process, and the ordinary next step is documentation rather than dispute.
Sometimes the carrier itself asks for it. On one Arrowhead job the carrier requested that we return to the property, re-inspect, photograph and submit findings so the claim could be reassigned. That is the carrier asking a contractor for documentation, which is exactly the role a roofing company is supposed to play.
What a good record contains: impacts circled and photographed on every slope rather than the best one, the exposed asphalt clearly visible so its colour can be read, soft metals showing the size and direction of what fell, interior moisture readings photographed with their location, and the whole thing annotated so a person who was not there can follow it.
What Changes the Answer
Three things decide how much room there is after a denial, and only the first is about the roof.
How complete the original inspection was
A first pass that covered one slope, or that photographed generally rather than specifically, leaves very little to work with. This is the part where who you had on the roof, and how they documented it, makes a measurable difference.
Whether the roof is on an age based schedule
More Oklahoma policies now settle an older roof at actual cash value under a roof schedule. That does not change whether damage exists, it changes what a covered loss pays, and it is a policy question rather than a roof question.
What the denial letter actually says
Read it closely, because the wording tells you which kind of denial it is. “No damage found” and “wear and tear” and “not a covered peril” are three different statements requiring three different responses, and only two of them have anything to do with your roof.
What We Do, and What We Do Not Do
We inspect roofs, document storm damage, provide inspection reports and detailed scope of work documentation, and meet insurance adjusters on site to support the inspection. We estimate in Xactimate, the same software the carriers use, and we annotate photographs so each distinct area of damage is identifiable.
Arrowhead Roofing is not a licensed public adjuster. We do not negotiate insurance claims. Coverage questions belong with your carrier or your agent, and after that with the Oklahoma Insurance Department’s consumer assistance line on 1-800-522-0071.
Related Questions
How do I show the damage is recent?
Colour, fracture edges, granule condition, and spatter on soft metals, read together. How can you tell old hail damage from new hail damage? sets out each indicator and how precise it really is.
What is the adjuster actually looking for up there?
Fractures in the shingle mat, counted within test squares on each direction, plus corroborating evidence on the soft metals. What does an adjuster look for on a roof? walks through the whole inspection.
They said the hail was too small to do anything.
Three quarter inch is the most common size in Tulsa, and the 2025 research on cumulative damage is more interesting than either side of the usual argument. Can 3/4-inch hail damage a roof? covers it.
Does filing at all put the premium up?
On a policy in effect more than 45 days, Oklahoma prohibits cancelling, non-renewing or raising the premium solely because a first claim was filed. Will filing a roof claim raise your rates? covers the honest other half, which is that the protection is for the first claim only.
See Also
The two answers closest to this one are how a claim gets documented in the first place, and what happens when the number comes back low rather than at zero.
Get a Second Set of Photographs
We have documented storm damage on northeast Oklahoma roofs since 1987, and a denial is often a record that was never made properly the first time. Book a free roof inspection and we will tell you straight what is on your roof.